Recently Luckin Coffee (LK) issued a press release admitting that their chief operating officer had fabricated a significant amount of sales from the second quarter through the fourth quarter of 2019.  This caused Luckin Coffee share price to fall 82% in U.S. trading and leaving investor with little recourse.

Luckin, a rival of Starbucks in China, happen to be a fairly new public company that opened its initial public offering (IPO) in May 2019.  In the case of Luckin, investors needed to exercise caution when a company goes from zero to a $3 billion market capitalization valuation in less than two years.  Furthermore, it is important to understand that what occurred with Luckin Coffee can occur with other Chinese companies with stocks listed on U.S. equity market exchanges since they are not required to comply with Security and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) strict disclosure and transparency requirements.

Chinese stocks and emerging-markets stocks

China is the world’s second-largest economy and is still growing as an emerging market. Investing in young Chinese companies can be extremely risky.  Although the growth available in China is clearly appealing, there are a number of inherent risks for investors.  The risks include currency manipulation, ineffectual securities reporting standards, the draconian influence of China’s communist government, and the potential for financial fraud.

Recent economic and equity market history are rife with financial frauds and illegal activity related to Chinese companies listed on U.S. equity exchanges.  Many seasoned U.S. investors advise that Americans should avoid investing in Chinese stocks. They even recommend avoiding the few larger Chinese companies with established histories and strong management track records.

Delisting Chinese Stocks

To avoid future Luckin Coffee frauds perpetrated on unsuspecting American investors, “Chinese companies should be delisted from American exchanges if they don’t follow U.S. securities laws”, according to Senator Marco Rubio.  Senator Rubio believes that increase oversight is vitally required for Chinese and other foreign companies listed on American stock exchanges. In fact, he and colleagues have offered legislation that calls for delisting firms that are out of compliance with U.S. regulators for a period of three years.

Bottomline, it is difficult to trust the financial statements coming out of some high-flying companies based there. Fundamentals don’t matter if you can’t be sure the numbers are real and it is difficult to invest in Chinese companies that might be trying to deceive investors.

References:

1. https://finance.yahoo.com/news/luckin-coffee-chairman-defaults-loan-152735017.html
2. https://www.msn.com/en-us/finance/topstocks/investing-lessons-from-the-luckin-coffee-accounting-fraud-debacle/ar-BB12eas4
3. https://www.cnbc.com/2019/10/08/marco-rubio-chinese-firms-should-be-delisted-in-us-if-they-dont-follow-laws.html