“The more things change, the more they stay the same.”  Alphonse Karr

What a classic example demonstrated by a major U.S. financial institution of the quote “the more things change, the more they stay the same”.  The saying is a reference to situations where there appears to be a meaningful change, but many underlying fundamentals are still the same.

Recently, Charlie Scharf, Wells Fargo’s CEO, wrote in a June memo to employees, “While it might sound like an excuse, the unfortunate reality is that there is a very limited pool of Black to recruit from,” according to Reuters. Scharf also repeated this claim in a Zoom meeting over the summer, exasperating Black employees.

According to the Washington Post, less than 5 percent of those holding senior executive positions at Wells Fargo in 2018, a year before Scharf became chief executive officer, were Black.

Committing to diversity and inclusion shouldn’t just be a marketing ploy; it should just be who you are.

Like Wells Fargo, many corporations have released marketing statements committing to change and to the elimination of structural racism and racial inequality. But, they have not released comprehensive data on the racial diversity of their employees and in leadership positions to the public. Regrettably, we must assume that many CEOs harbor similar shortsighted beliefs, and they continue to embrace the excuse that there exist a paucity of Black executive talent in America.

“We value and promote diversity and inclusion in every aspect of our business and at every level of our organization” Wells Fargo’s Diversity and Inclusion Policy

Although Scharf apologized profusely for his bonehead remarks and commented that his remarks reflected his “own unconscious bias”, we must asks whether his beliefs, which one must assume is also the company’s mindset, have actually changed.

“The point isn’t to get people to accept that they have biases, but to get them to see [for themselves] that those biases have negative consequences for others.” — Theresa McHenry, HR Director at Microsoft UK

“Wells Fargo is badly broken in multiple ways and that starts at the top,” Senator Elizabeth Warren commented. “Its CEO has an unfathomable blind spot about how and why this giant bank fails to hire, promote, and fairly compensate Black talent.”

Consequently, it’s difficult to argue against Senator Warren’s point. Since, the primary benefit of hiring from a racially and gender diverse talent pool is that it immediately expands the depth of the pool and increases your chances of hiring the best executive talent.

References:

1. https://www.businessinsider.com/aoc-sherrod-brown-criticize-wells-fargo-ceo-scharf-black-talent-2020-9
2. https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/wells-fargo-ceo-issues-apology-after-saying-there-was-a-limited-pool-of-black-talent/ar-BB19mize?ocid=uxbndlbing